April 25, 2025| By SOUF Team
The 2025 NFL Draft Grades have wrapped up, and teams across the league are busy reshaping their rosters in preparation for the upcoming season. From strategic trades to high-profile selections and addressing particular needs, the draft is crucial in determining a team’s success moving forward. With plenty of teams making daring moves, we’ve taken the time to evaluate each pick and ranked all 32 teams based on their draft performance, ranging from the least to the most impressive.
Atlanta Falcons – Draft Grade: D
The Atlanta Falcons certainly raised some eyebrows during the NFL draft Grades, leaving both fans and analysts scratching their heads. With the second overall pick, they opted for quarterback Ruke Orhorhoro, despite already having Kirk Cousins as their long-term starting quarterback. This decision, along with not addressing critical gaps in the defensive line and secondary, has sparked a lot of conversations. While Orhorhoro has potential, many feel this choice was a bit ambitious given the talent available in other positions. All in all, it was a draft that didn’t quite inspire confidence and has folks questioning the team’s long-term game plan.
Washington Commanders – Draft Evaluation: C
The Washington Commanders headed into the 2025 NFL draft Grades with a pressing need to bolster their receiving group, yet they chose to focus heavily on the safety position. Although they made headlines by signing Deebo Samuel in the offseason, they passed on the opportunity to secure a true game-changing wide receiver in an NFL draft filled with exceptional talent. Instead of enhancing their offensive lineup, they opted for a defensive strategy with their first three picks. This bold choice has backfired, and the Commanders will likely come to regret missing out on the chance to bring in top-tier receiving talent in the future.
New York Giants – Draft Grade: C
The Giants made a wise decision by choosing Malik Nabers, a nimble wide receiver, with their first pick; however, the overall NFL draft Grades lacked the necessary depth to make a significant impact. The team did not adequately address other key weaknesses in the roster, particularly in the offensive line and defensive backfield. Although Nabers is anticipated to improve the passing game, there are ongoing concerns about the Giants’ capacity to meet their other requirements.
Los Angeles Rams – Evaluation of Draft: C+
The Los Angeles Rams approached the NFL draft Grades with hopes of bouncing back from a challenging season, though their strategy felt rather cautious. They certainly addressed some pressing needs, particularly in strengthening their defensive line, but none of their picks stood out as transformative. Instead, the Rams focused on dependable players who might make a difference in the long run, yet they didn’t take any significant risks that could have hastened their rebuilding efforts.
Miami Dolphins – Draft Grade: B-
The Miami Dolphins executed several astute selections during the NFL draft Grades; however, it was overshadowed by missed opportunities. They successfully enhanced their offensive line and addressed certain secondary requirements, yet the absence of a remarkable pick is disappointing. Although Miami did not engage in any high-profile trades, its draft was consistent and filled several significant gaps. Nevertheless, their roster appears to be one or two components away from being a championship contender.
New England Patriots – Draft Grade: B
The Patriots, recognized for their careful and strategic drafting style, had an NFL draft Grades in 2025 that was solid yet lacked any real excitement. They made safe choices, focusing on reinforcing the offensive line and addressing needs in the defensive backfield. However, the absence of a standout player left many fans questioning whether Bill Belichick’s team might have overlooked some potential future stars. While their selections were compatible with their system, they didn’t take the bold risks that could have provided an immediate lift to the roster.
Denver Broncos – Draft Grade: B+
The Broncos made several significant selections, especially in the areas of defense and the offensive line. Their choice of Edge Rusher Jaden Ivey in the first round has the potential to yield substantial benefits, while their offensive line selections offer essential protection for quarterback Russell Wilson. Although they did not make any standout picks, Denver’s draft effectively targeted critical needs, which could lead to considerable enhancement in their performance.
Carolina Panthers – Draft Grade: B+
The Panthers made a bold move by selecting wide receiver Tetairoa McMillan with the eighth overall pick. This pick provides Bryce Young, their young quarterback, with a true number-one receiver. McMillan’s size and speed give Carolina a legitimate weapon in the passing game, something they haven’t had since D.J. Moore. Instead of making a significant investment in their offense, the Panthers still need to address some issues on defense, especially in the secondary.
Arizona Cardinals – Draft Grade: B+
The draft conducted by the Arizona Cardinals was characterized by sound decision-making and a consistent approach. They effectively addressed multiple critical needs, especially in defensive positions and along the line of scrimmage. The selection of Defensive Tackle Quinton Williams in the first round is expected to have an immediate effect on run defense and quarterback pressure. The Cardinals’ strategic choices are likely to enhance their defensive capabilities in the years ahead.
Chicago Bears – Draft Grade: B+
With a clear focus on rebuilding their defense, the Bears made several impactful picks, including the selection of Cornerback Devon Johnson in the first round. Their draft was solid overall, with a mix of youth and experience in key positions. However, Chicago didn’t make the kind of splash that would’ve pushed them to a higher ranking. Still, the future looks promising, and their picks should help them compete in the NFC North.
Detroit Lions – Draft Grade: B+
The Lions made solid choices in the 2025 draft, but they didn’t quite hit the home run they were hoping for. While they added some depth to their defensive line and offensive line, there were no truly electrifying picks. Still, with a focus on building a balanced roster, the Lions should see steady improvements over the next few seasons.
Minnesota Vikings – Draft Grade: B+
The Vikings, similar to the Lions, adopted a cautious approach during the 2025 draft. Although they did not create significant headlines, their choices were prudent and will address critical needs. The Vikings enhanced their roster by adding depth at wide receiver and cornerback, areas that require attention for them to be competitive in the NFC. Should these players progress as anticipated, the Vikings may emerge as playoff contenders in the coming years.
Summary :
The 2025 NFL Draft Grades provided ample drama, impressive trades, and unpredictable picks. Some teams nailed their selections and set themselves up for future success, while others left many scratching their heads. The true impact of these picks will be seen in the coming seasons, but based on immediate needs and overall strategy, this ranking gives fans a glimpse into how teams performed in securing their futures.
